The Best Carbon Steel Pans for 2026: Mauviel, Misen, OXO and More
By Claire Whitmore. Last updated October 2026.
Disclosure: some links on this page are affiliate links, including Amazon links. If you buy through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It doesn’t change what we recommend. Details are in our affiliate disclosure.
Carbon steel is the pan professional cooks reach for when they want cast iron’s searing power without its weight. Like cast iron, it handles ripping-high heat, works on gas, electric and induction, goes in the oven or on a grill, and becomes more nonstick the more you cook with it. Unlike cast iron, it’s thinner, lighter and quicker to respond when you turn the heat up or down, and its sloped sides make tossing vegetables easy.
To build this guide, we compared two independent testing programs. Serious Eats tested 17 carbon steel pans, cooking over-easy eggs and crepes in every model, then searing chicken, sautéing broccoli and baking an onion tarte tatin in the finalists. Food & Wine ran its own carbon steel tests and named a different pan, the French-made Matfer Bourgeat, its best overall, which makes for a useful contrast. Where they agree, we’re confident; where they differ, we explain why. We haven’t tested these pans ourselves, and prices change often.
Quick answer: for a traditional pan you season yourself, get the Mauviel M’Steel Black Carbon Steel 11-inch Frying Pan, Serious Eats’ favorite since 2023. If you want to cook eggs on day one, get a pre-seasoned pan: the OXO Obsidian 10-inch was the slickest pan Serious Eats has ever used, and the Misen Pre-Seasoned 10-inch has the biggest cooking surface of the winners.

Our picks at a glance
| Pick | Type | Cooking surface | Max oven temp | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mauviel M’Steel Black 11-inch | Traditional | 8.5 in. | 680 °F | Cooks who’ll season it themselves |
| OXO Obsidian Pre-Seasoned 10-inch | Pre-seasoned | 8 in. | 660 °F | Eggs out of the box; light weight |
| Misen Pre-Seasoned 10-inch | Pre-seasoned | 10.8 in. | 500 °F (sleeve 350 °F) | Maximum surface in a 10-inch pan |
| Merten & Storck Pre-Seasoned 10-inch | Pre-seasoned | 8 in. | 660 °F | Budget; straighter sides |
| Misen Carbon Nonstick 10-inch | Nitrided | 9 in. | 1,100 °F | Rust resistance; lightest pick |
| Yeti Carbon Steel Pan | Nitrided | 8 in. | 800 °F | Grill and campfire use |
| Vollrath Carbon Steel Fry Pan | Traditional | 7.6 in. | 600 °F | Restaurant-style budget pan |
Specs from Serious Eats’ testing. Note how much a pan’s listed size (its rim) can differ from its flat cooking surface.
The best carbon steel pans
1. Mauviel M’Steel Black Carbon Steel 11-Inch Frying Pan: best traditional pan
Best for: cooks who enjoy building their own seasoning and want an heirloom French pan.
Once properly seasoned, the Mauviel cooked crepes and eggs without sticking in Serious Eats’ tests, its handle stayed relatively cool compared with similar designs, and its surface is big enough to cook for two or three people. It has been the site’s top carbon steel pick since 2023.
It’s on the heavy side, and the long handle feels a little awkward when swirling crepe batter or flipping food. Eggs stuck at first until the seasoning built up, and an acidic onion filling caused some sticking in the tarte tatin test. That’s typical of a new traditional pan, which is why we’d recommend it to people who enjoy the ritual of seasoning rather than to anyone who wants instant results.
Pros
- Excellent release once seasoned
- Handle stays relatively cool
- Generous cooking surface
- Oven-safe to 680 °F
Cons
- Heavier than pre-seasoned picks
- Needs a break-in period
- Long handle
2. OXO Obsidian Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel 10-Inch Skillet: best pre-seasoned pan for most people
Best for: anyone switching from nonstick who wants carbon steel without the learning curve.
Serious Eats called it the most nonstick pan it has ever used, including ceramic- and Teflon-coated pans. At just over 2.5 pounds it was one of the lightest pans tested, it heated evenly, and its removable silicone sleeve keeps the handle cool.
The only complaint: because it’s so light, it sometimes spun when bumped on glass cooktops. Its 8-inch cooking surface is smaller than the Misen’s, so it’s best for one or two people or for eggs and side dishes.
Pros
- Exceptionally slick out of the box
- Very light
- Cool silicone handle sleeve
- Affordable
Cons
- Can spin on glass cooktops
- Smaller cooking surface
3. Misen Pre-Seasoned 10-Inch Carbon Steel Pan: best for cooking space
Best for: small kitchens that want a big working surface in a pan that stores easily.
Eggs, seared chicken, broccoli and crepes all slid readily out of the Misen in Serious Eats’ testing. Though sold as a 10-inch pan, its 10.8-inch cooking surface was the largest of any winner, bigger even than a 12-inch Vollrath, because its sides flare less. The silicone-sleeved handle is grippy, and one editor singled it out as unusually comfortable for sautéing.
The sleeve is only rated to 350 °F, so you’ll remove it for oven work, and the handle is less comfortable without it. Some fond stuck after searing chicken, though coarse salt scrubbed it away easily.
Pros
- Largest cooking surface of the winners
- Ready to use
- Comfortable handle
Cons
- Handle sleeve only to 350 °F
- A little weighty
4. Merten & Storck Pre-Seasoned 10-Inch Carbon Steel Frying Pan: best budget pan
Best for: budget shoppers, campers and cooks who also bake and simmer.
Nonstick from the box and well balanced for one-handed use, the Merten & Storck has straighter, cast-iron-like sides that make it a little more versatile for baking and simmering. Serious Eats found it for under $50. Its flat handle was a bit uncomfortable and got warm during cooking.
Pros
- Under $50 at testing
- Ready to use
- Versatile straighter sides
Cons
- Handle gets warm
- Less comfortable grip
5. Misen Carbon Nonstick and Yeti Carbon Steel Pan: best nitrided pans
Best for: cooks who want extra rust resistance or plan to cook over fire.
Nitriding hardens carbon steel by exposing it to nitrogen at high temperature, making the surface tougher and more rust-resistant. The Misen Carbon Nonstick, with an aluminum core, is the lightest winner at 2.5 pounds and is oven-safe to an extraordinary 1,100 °F. The pricier Yeti seared steak evenly, tossed onions easily, was functionally nonstick right away and is oven-safe to 800 °F.
Serious Eats adds a useful caution: it found nitrided pans seem slicker at first, but their performance evens out with ordinary pre-seasoned pans within weeks or months, and you still have to season them. Buy nitrided for durability and rust resistance, not as a Teflon substitute.
Pros
- Very rust-resistant
- Extremely high heat limits
- Ready to use
Cons
- Not truly nonstick
- Still needs seasoning
- Yeti is pricey
6. Vollrath Carbon Steel Fry Pan: best budget traditional pan
Best for: cooks who want a no-frills restaurant pan.
Built for commercial kitchens, the super-light Vollrath heated quickly and made beautifully seared chicken, lacy crepes and flaky tarte tatin. Its high, sloped sides are great for tossing, but they also shrink the flat cooking surface to about 7.6 inches. The long handle gets hot, some owners report warping, and its warranty doesn’t cover non-commercial use.
Pros
- Very light and fast
- Great for tossing
- Inexpensive
Cons
- Small cooking surface
- Hot handle
- Warranty excludes home use
7. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel 11-Inch Fry Pan: the chef’s choice
Best for: cooks who want the classic restaurant pan and don’t mind weight.
This is where our sources disagree. Food & Wine named the Matfer Bourgeat the best carbon steel pan overall in its tests, praising its balanced weight, restaurant-grade durability and one-piece uncoated construction, and noted it sold for about $107 at Amazon for the 11-inch size. Serious Eats liked its slick surface but found it unwieldy at almost four pounds, with a relatively small cooking area better suited to one or two people.
Our take: if you cook with two hands, mostly sear and want the pan you’ll see stacked in professional kitchens, the Matfer is a superb buy. If you sauté with one hand or want something light, choose the OXO or Misen.
Pros
- Restaurant-grade durability
- One piece of uncoated steel
- Food & Wine’s top pick
Cons
- Almost 4 pounds
- Needs seasoning
- Smaller cooking surface

Pans the testers didn’t love
Serious Eats found the Smithey Carbon Steel Farmhouse Skillet hard to justify at its price because eggs and crepes stuck. The De Buyer Mineral B Pro, beloved by chefs, was too heavy for comfortable one-handed use and needed more seasoning time. The Made In Blue Carbon Steel pan had awkwardly high sides and eggs stuck despite its factory seasoning, though Made In suggests cooking only fatty foods for the first few uses. The pre-seasoned Lodge produced pale, uneven crepes.
Carbon steel vs. cast iron vs. nonstick
Carbon steel vs. cast iron: both are durable, hold heat well and become virtually nonstick when seasoned. Carbon steel is lighter, thinner and more responsive, with sloped sides for sautéing; cast iron holds heat longer and is better for deep, heavy pans and baking. Many cooks own both. See our guide to the best cast-iron skillets.
Carbon steel vs. nonstick: a PTFE nonstick pan is still the easiest choice for delicate eggs and fish, but its coating wears out in a few years and shouldn’t be used over very high heat. Carbon steel can sear at any temperature, has no synthetic coating, and can last a lifetime; our nonstick pan guide covers the trade-offs.
What to look for
- Pre-seasoned or traditional: pre-seasoned pans are ready right away; traditional pans give you control but need a break-in period.
- Weight: Serious Eats found pans under about 3.5 pounds easiest to lift and toss with one hand.
- Cooking surface, not rim size: flared sides can shrink a 12-inch pan’s usable surface below a 10-inch pan’s.
- Handle: rounded edges and a length of about 7 to 9 inches; silicone sleeves add comfort but limit oven use.
- Oven limit: all of these handle high heat, but check sleeves and coatings.
How to season and care for carbon steel
Unseasoned pans ship with a protective coating, often wax. Remove it per the maker’s instructions, dry the pan immediately (it can rust quickly) and heat it on high. Buff in a very thin layer of neutral oil such as canola or grapeseed with a lint-free, polyester-free towel, and keep heating until it smokes. Repeat several times. Your first few cooks should be fatty, like searing steak, which builds seasoning faster.
After cooking, wipe it out or scrub gently with warm water, a little soap and a brush, then dry it over a burner and rub in a few drops of oil. Avoid long-simmered acidic sauces, which strip seasoning. Blotchy color and dark patina are normal. If rust appears, scrub it off and re-season; a carbon steel pan is almost never ruined.
FAQ
Does carbon steel work on induction?
Yes. It’s magnetic, so it works on induction as well as gas, electric, grills and campfires.
Is a pre-seasoned pan worth it?
For most people, yes. In Serious Eats’ tests, nearly every pre-seasoned pan produced perfect over-easy eggs and crepes immediately, while most traditional pans stuck at first.
Can I put carbon steel in the dishwasher?
No. It will rust and lose its seasoning.
Why is my pan sticky or splotchy?
Too much oil during seasoning causes stickiness; splotches even out with use. Heat it again to burn off excess oil.
The bottom line
If you want a pan you’ll shape yourself over years, buy the Mauviel M’Steel. If you want carbon steel that cooks like nonstick from the first egg, the OXO Obsidian is the easy recommendation. Choose the Misen pre-seasoned pan for the most cooking room, and the Merten & Storck to spend less.